On our way into Valentine we find the fairly obvious trail of a serial killer and pick up Killer Clue 1, which is the first part of a map we need to piece together it would seem, by finding the other parts around the map.
Then we head over to John Marston who has a sheep rustling mission for us, but first we have to buy a rolling block rifle – with a scope – before we head out south-east of Valentine to find the ranch hands with their herd. We scare them off and go do some herding of our own, back to Valentine to sell.
Afterwards, we’re instructed to head to the saloon to meet Dutch, and that’s when things turn a bit, when Leviticus Cornwall turns up in town looking for the men who robbed his train! I won’t spoil the rest, but I think you can see where this is going…